Umineko - Chapter 1
this is really funny that they let you do this
DUDE what is this
bro drinking baja blast
fuck i dont know chess
wtf contract like madoka
why she got the freaky font
majoras mask reference
1986 reference
who the fuck is just called george
dude.
banger
? what she mean by this
this guy is gonna 100% be a protagonist of all time
kill
dude shut this thing up
nvm kill him
why this look like a final fantasy logo
kill
dude
kill
dude fuck off
a walmart goes crazy here
noting
very interesting that they're using rainy days as a motif of "unchanging days" here instead of what it was in higu
higuposting
I THOUGHT MAGIC DIDNT EXIST
Maria saw a Torii gate was missing on the way to the island im NOTING THIS
OST - Hope is a cool ass song damn
he's popping ult
hmmmm....
magic is real!!!!
wtf she SHOT ME
why does he have that sprite
die
LMFAOOOOOO THIS GUY
HOLY SHIT IT STHE THING
beatrice portrait 2 year ago....
SHOW THEM YOUR FONT BABE
very oyashiro-sama core... hmmm....
wtf sexism
why bro got elixirs
he has the temu witch setup
banger
"my kids and grandkids are all fucking chuds"
bro its more phrases from higurashi
its betting coins... all the way down....
jjk powerscaling ass
i am very surprised that this is all filled out so early
wokekichi strikes again
I am still very interested in what the Inciting Incident will be
I am assuming its either Kinzo's Death while everyone is here or some Beatrice shit all of a sudden
Because Higurashi has a very clear Moment where things start to go off the rails in chapter 1
i wonder what that will be here
i love the designs just literally spamming the shit out of the little crest
dont turn to face me
damn he literally just said shut up woman
wokekichi strikes again
oh yeah events that i need to pay attention to - 14 years ago i think rosa (?) was getting harassed at the house
last year they tried to force kinzo out of his room
eva killing herself if she lives to today lol
rthgak u krauss4 foir the reference
holy shit a cg already
they did this NVL mode thing before, I need to pay attention to if this is only ever done from kumasawa's perspective or not... interesting....
we love the wokeler
what
the clock jusat went back
wtf
[i apparently noted how much i liked the song Hope again lol]
beatrice origins
"it's obviously fake" most wrong guy ever btw
beatrice voice "okay now hit the second tower"
thank you chudlet
this is a cool little thing
good ass scene with the adults talking damn
what fucking miracle bro
kinzo is king crashout man
so yeah i need to hammer into my brain this is how magic works in this world
i wonder if this is what people mean by it being much more directly a riddle to solve from ryukishi
"You must also challenge it." is a really cool little thing
i really like kinzo going "lend me your full strength shannon, i need to spirit bomb summon beatrice"
RIDDLE EPITAPH thank fuck i thought they were just gonna hide this from me forever
oh that's a cute end card for the chapter like that and different from getting my screen shattered with a gun
cute
I am assuming that this is gonna be a key part of battler's character - it definitely seems that way. he seems really enamoured with some of the mysteries of the island after being gone for 6 years
wow interesting
wow inter
they are talking a lot about beatrice like the higurashi god
"she is the protector of this island and the wild"
also extremely The Tempest coded
i wonder how much intertextuality we will be seeing in this
why is this thing our takano
without love.... it cannot be protective...
waow like beatrice despawning
it cannot be seen....
chill out lmfao
child neglect world champion right here
yeah this is probably good
bro no way ur summoning a devil at 5pm
thats baby hours
omega, count every grain of sand in this desert
it is really funny that they have to like
spam "ushiromiya" on every name in the log
i know more chars will show up but like
its really funny
this seems good i think
witches are real and they told me to read to you
UUU UUUUU
interesting that we are no longer Battler POV for this scene...
oh wow
THE SHANNON STEAL IS INCOMING
interesting....
kinda And Then There Were None coded tbh
he believes..
what an odd little phrase
the 19th person doesn't know that they're mysteryfiends....
interesting... So, mr ryukishi is signalling that we should be constantly thinking about motives - "flipping over the chessboard" is how we can actually think about and understand contradictions in the minds of these characters.... i will keep this in mind. also this is kyrie's ult
also really funny "my reasoning will just fall apart but i'm certain it's true"
woah rudolf
uh
natsuhi you good
maria deadass has that real shit on her
i know battler wasn't gonna die right away but its nice to be sure
wait bro night 1 has SIX deaths???? i was not ready for 6 i thought it'd be like 4 omfg
or like 2
uh oh
so what thats:
Krauss
Rudolf
Rosa
Kyrie
Gohda
1 more we gotta see
very interesting that the georgelers are unscathed
and that natsuhi was possibly supposed to die but didn't
so what does that mean?
Eva and her Husband being alive is kinda suspicious for her? But that's like, WAY too obvious. If this is an actual pattern though, this suggests that a human chose them for a reason (either they did it or are being set up)
BUT
Natsuhi being alive because of a charm kinda suggests that it was magic that killed them all???? but where is more of this blood??? did gohda just clean it up and not tell anyone????
#whathemeanbythat
cute scene
coulda said this shit before your sons were killed but yk yk
uh
this is probably good
uhhhhhhhhh
holy moly OST - goldenslaughterer is kinda crazy
i like this little line as battler subconciously trying to solve a mystery here
:(
:((((((
deeply evil shit
damn a cg for this?
mystery genre commentary
"man eva is super suspicious but i dont think she knows that im so sneaky"
damn i like this battler is cool
what are we DOING here dude
so that's talking about the conversation that Keiichi has with his mother during Tatarigoroshi (Ch 3) I think?
If I remember right, that one is about eliminating a "mystery" occurring alltogether from making it find out nobody finds out about the crime in the first place?
so the fact that the bodies were found is the issue over all else
NANJO FORGOTTEN
HUH???
Is this written by maria??????????
okay maria being a sick little freak who writes stuff like that is becoming more likely, you don't get an evil fisheye lense image unless ur insane and evil
chhudling :(
okay its definitely evil i think
OST - Core is extremely YTTD coded for that first half wtf i like it a lot
what a cool fucking guy
no fucking shot she got the mion sonozaki blicky on her
wait this is chekov's gun fuck off
They are really really trying to push this "binary choice" thing - they are spamming "Either the 19th person exists, or it doesn't", "Beatrice exists, or doesn't", "the gold exists or doesn't", "it's either magic, or humans".
Really interested to see how this will evolve.
will the story turn into "One of these is correct, pick your side", or will it be "There is a secret 3rd option/compromise" that exists"? Intriguing to see
clues
there is red goop on natsuhi door
there is red goop that drew on the garden shed door (kinzo and maria are the only ones who know magic enough to draw the circle)
there is no location that is obviously the crime scene
there is a reason why the heads and faces were smashed in
there is a reason why those people were chosen (setting up kinzo and eva? random?)
very higurashi as well - keiichi wanting anyone to tell him the truth
worked by his side is interesting
ghost....?
also is she destroying their faces because she's jealous of them existing and being able to be real in the human world? because she can't be seen?
dont follow evil butterflies.... noted....
"magic isn't real" chuds in shambles rn
WITHOUT LOVE IT CANNOT BE SEEN
fnaf 1
huh????
beatrice hates him because he can't see her, and therefore doesn't confirm her existence?
very higurashi once again
she's just a little sad......
ace attourney mf
this is fucking AWESOME this scene rocks
"gotcha, magic isn't real, show me some cold hard proof"
she will play touys with me :D
interesting, so maria wanted to be unique so badly that she tulpa'd herself
RACIST BATTLER - CANCELLED
he's saying the servants only believe in her because Kinzo is influencing them? interesting
POPPING ULT
Battler is trying to insist that Beatrice was definitely trying to prove her existence, so doing it at the middle of the night is stupid? i mean i guess he's real...
Okay so I need to be thinking about why the hell they did the crime EXACTLY then too - i guess that makes sense, with the murder happening without anyone finding them UNTIL morning
i love u chessboard...
This rule thing is very Higurashi too.
The rule is: If you can't explain something in human terms, then it has to be the work of Beatrice.
Which means, any character can cloak what they're doing as a witch's work by making it unsolvable/unexplainable in human terms.
Cool idea.
Really cute scene, I gotta figure out what this means now...
clues
there is red goop on natsuhi door
there is red goop that drew on the garden shed door (kinzo and maria are the only ones who know magic enough to draw the circle)
there is no location that is obviously the crime scene (dining room has some blood but so does hallway)
there is a reason why the heads and faces were smashed in
there is a reason why those people were chosen (setting up kinzo and eva? random?)
there is a reason why the death happened at that TIME - everyone was asleep - night is the least impressive/magical time for a murder to happen. {So why did they do it then, if wanting to make it look like magic death?}
These are the points I can tie together rn
Oh battler thinks that the culprit wants people to solve it for them - maybe to swoop in and steal the money after everyone finds it? Interesting
i love him he's so moe
Natsuhi had the key, but couldn't he buzz people in and out? I'm sure this will not be overlooked, but, hmm...
Getting death note'd in 1986 is crazy holy
so this means one of these must be true:
He was never in the room in the first place (When Natsuhi was in, he was already gone. Illusion)
He never left the room in the first place (Hidden somewhere in it)
He left the room in another way instead (Servants lying about hidden door/magic/nobody knew)
Eva is lying about this reciept (It didn't exist/lying about the fact it was at the perfect height or something)
The door can open in a manner that doesn't release the paper (Swings the opposite hings/slides up or something stupid)
I think it must be one of these, but i must be missing something
HOLY crashout cg
is everyone in this game just gonna be constantly crashing out
i heart diagramslop
he's so fucking cool
okay i am really excited for this guy to pop off i like battler a lot
his mom dies and he starts spamming this shit lmfao
WOOO MY THEORIES
NOO MY THEORIES HOW CAN I MISS HIM LITERALLY JUST RUNNING OUT WHEN THE DOOR OPENS
EITO AOTSUKI MAN THAT YOU ARE
god he's so cool
GOD HE'S SO COOL (DANGANRONPA)
plot cancered at such a young age... so sad...
they dont make representation for bad bitches with inhalers anymore
she's so getting killed with this lock it in
its real believe me its real believe me its r
family guy.... title drop... holy
.
just like higurashi...
beatrice as a convenient truth is a pretty cool idea. not my battler though, he would never
bro called the demon that teleports you "Gap" ok dude
without x, y cannot be seen
pretty neat idea - beatrice is not quite a person, so we need to count her as such. might come up later. hmmm.
this is an interesting question but realistically I think both the servants think that they are pawns (furniture) and Kinzo thinks of EVERYONE as such. Considering that he needs to take a risk to resummon beatrice, everyone is worth the same to him.
Maybe he counts himself as the king? Being a unit that he cannot allow to die? He wants to see her face after all. Maybe he's crazy enough to put himself in check to have the possibility of checkmating them?
cute.,... its so cute even if they'll die...
actually so dead goodbye one of you
or these two will get torn apart because it's night two
anyone could have drawn the circle...
is this another locked room mystery what the fuck
WHY IS THE KEYHOLE UPSIDE DOWN
wait yeah did kinzo give them this? or is it trying to suggest they posted it from the inside
slowly opened the door (ddlc)
AIEEEE A LOCK AIEEEE ITS IMPOSSIBLE
yeah that's probably good. that's on the door of eva's room
wait this happened midday not during the night???
without getting close, it cannot be cut....
welp
it's soooo sus....
oh
they find someone in a hot bath in higurashi is this a refference
yeah thats definitely maria huh
barely an hour...
battler crying for others.... cute... but what does he actually believe...
he's so COOL even if he's crashing out
DUDE CHILL
GAME THEORY: the doors are bleeding.
dude wtf fastest lock in of all time
diagramslop.... my beloved...
hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
dude he has two ults this is awesome
literally said "i want to hit her so bad" out loud 1 sec bfore
dude they have like isaac items what are you meant to do
interesting, it can like, give you a flip the chessboard moment. it's just symbolic of thinking differently.
I love when we get formatting
dude its like higurashi fucuuuuckkkk
UHHHH
HE'S AURAFARMING POP OFF
DUDE
RESPECTFULLY you arent doing anything
uh
UHHHH
HOLY SHIT
I have some interesting thoughts about where the story might take us now - mainly that we may be in reboot territory like higurashi
OST - Requiem goes insane
I DONT TRUST YOU YOU FUCKER
damn he REALLY cares about this shit uh....
when the UMINEKO naku koro ni...
holy..
limbus reference
#yep
why are we not trying to show off two of these kills? kanon sure, but why not magic circle for kinzo?
the toeler
without seen it cannot be rare
huh....................... why stab these 4, and not the first six (that we know of)
this is kinda the nail in the coffin for me. We are doing Higurashi bullshit where it's a different roguelike run every time.
We MIGHT be doing some nonsense with reviving people but you do NOT kil half your cast just to not do more of it
OST - Mind goes nutty
BIGASS CLOCK DUDE
tear the limb and kill
goddamn it it's way too obvious to be any human it's literally gotta be magic
wait did she always have a fang
cute
is it just christian heaven? hm,mmm
the story of umineko will be more and more people going "maybe rosa had a point damn"
very much expecting a like, wake up and near everyone is dead. it feels like we are nearing the end now
"dude shut up you are killing the vibe"
you are acting actually insane dude no
he is about to be killed and he is still in "i want to solve the puzzle :D" mode
WOOOO ULT
the theory "they haven't shown off its possible, so they must be bluffing" is an interesting take. they do not need to show off to u that bad
"wait what dude i didnt actually mean it"
hmmm
mini ult
nvm big ult
he is losing his MIND and so am i
oh that's really cute that he was fixated on it. interesting, i wonder what that says about him as a person that he used to be so happy to think like this - it seems a really combative way to be thinking all the time
"please stop spamming my ult it's not cool anymore"
i'm liking these sorts of chats a lot
Interesting. the "same thing occurs more than once" and this whole thing is pretty obviously going to be how we do chapters here, much like Higurashi. Higurashi explained this concept near the end, but I wonder how Umineko will tackle it. Extremely interested in this.
yeah this is exactly my thought - we have been told that Beatrice is highly emotional, and should probably treat her as a wild card right now. we do not know how she functions or what her goal is other than "kill everyone to revive"
WAIT FUCK WE HAVENT OPENED THE LETTER YET SHIT
like magic WOOOO ITS ALL FUCKED
or like a ritual that Kinzo knows how this shit works but nobody else does i suppose
uyhhhhh fuck dude its all so fried also he hit mini ult
i think it's cute that he likes kyrie so much without admitting it. she made a huge impact on him at the very least.
why are we powerscaling the door
scorpion upscale
incredibly powerful image
it does call to question why kinzo would not commission a painting of beatrice for his room. weird.
is this talking about how Beatrice might kill all of them, but the ritual will not be completed properly, so she cannot get checkmate? "rushed and never completed" is a really interesting way to phrase it after all.
Is it just how Kinzo's own goals were rushed and he couldn't see Beatrice in this timeline? Hmmm
NEVER MIND LMFAO
holy finally
thank you beatorice...
deified is crazy
huh
i mean i guess you need to be dead to be revived but he's talking as if she is a human, not a demon alive for a 1000 years like Kanon suggested
the marriage was without love so it ca
interesting, i look forwards to see him explored more later
cute idea but like kanon had a knife spawned in him dude
i like the idea of it being infectious - i wonder if this will be expanded on in any future loops. I can easily see any of these pairs choosing to try it. Or even Battler trying magic to save everyone
this is a really weird and stilted line i feel. very odd. oh well, i am sure they will expand on this in future
i forgot if this was the kanon shannon house
yes
kinzo's private island does not look too good in 2026 huh
crashout time
HIGURASHI REFERENCE
yeah its just higurashi power system
so the note was just saying the note itself is the second twilight? weird
then kinzo is the 4th (head got)
kanon got his stomach got
The witch's epitaph is quite a lot like the Watanagashi fucking everything up in higu too
banger
wait thats really funny
HUH. damn this is wild
holy crashout
holy aura
fighting with an 8 year old is so good
holy banger
holy
damn good point, you send out 3 people for the killer to kill lol
holy fake dgafer
welp
when the umineko no naku koro ni 2
BIG ASS FUCKING CLOCK
:((((((((((
its gonna be a fun time seeing how woke ryukishi is and how feminist his take on witches are
mini ult
INTO BIG ULT
if the culprit was in the room - it makes sense for them to make it look like it came from outside
and versa
begging to change your theory is cute
waow become a demon like higurashi
magic to cause domestic argument goes nuclear tbh
oh that shouldnt be happening. uh oh.
uhhhhhhhhhhhh
i mean the goal could be to get you out the room
thats pretty bad too
this is just like higurashi chapter 8
you literally will lose this fight what
#yep
extremely obvious, and it's meant to be
wtf FUCKED UP CG
YEAH THIUS IS PROBABLY FINE
WITHOUT FEELINGS IT CANNOT BE SAVED
what the FUCK are we doing
#1 anti magic guy
DUDE
FUCK
OST - Dead Angle GOES INSANE
holy shit
HOLY
lowdiffed im afraid
yeah this is extremely christian heaven
HE'S HITTING THE HIGURASHI YES
she's just actually here????
holy shit they're withholding the sprites these bitches
this scene and a lot of this second half has felt very zero escape 999 to me
GET OUT MY FUCKING FACE
what the fuck dude
and of course they spam you with like a hundred baffling facts after the fact, it wouldn't be ryukishi otherwise
not found?????
interesting that maria is the narrator for chapter 1 because i do not fucking trust her. unreliable narrator is a possibility for these questions that arise as a result of "dude the butterflies are here and stabbed kanon"
only maria's jaw????? huh????????
DUDE THEY ARE FUCKING HIGURASHI POSTING AGAIN I CANNOT HANDLE THIS
Everyone but battler accepted it??? huh????
the gold piece is real....
WOOOOOO AFTER CHAPTER DISSCUSSION HAS RETURNED!!!! I MISSED YOU
iconic, i loved in higurashi everyone was saying "dude i died in such a fucked up way its not fair"
now who will be our Tomitake?
okay i am immediately suspicious of this. "miricales wont happen if you dont believe" is a rika thing, and we still have the Bernkastle thing from Higurashi to resolve. Is this suggesting Rika will be a witch????? uhhhhh
ACTUALLY OOMF
"uh. guys. you're taking the easy way out. what got into all of you?"
wait this is really cool we're getting an actually interesting after party that directly follows on from the story, and quite frankly, seems more combatative than the main story?
"is that too much...?" i really like him desperately trying to rationalise this to ANY extent this is awesome
me and the person I have been playing against have named such as "Device-posting". If you say "it had to be humans who used x sci fi or convoluted Device to kill someone", they get you now.
BANGER LINE "BRO THERES SO MUCH CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE"
It appears as though we are taking a similar stance to Witch on the Holy Night.
Anything is magic if you cannot explain it. Subsequently, if you can explain it, then that means it isn't "True Magic". Interesting.
okay we are just spamming higurashi posting holy shit
DOUBLE ULT
WHAT
WHY ARE YOU HERE I ASSUMED IF WE DIDN'T SEE YOU IN THE CHAPTER WE ARENT GETTING A SPRITE AFTER IT WHAT THE FUCK WHAT THE FUCK DUDE WHAT ARE WE DOING
fictional being??? wtf?????
magic will fall short against him, interesting
it can be seen but it cannot exist
FREAKY. THESE QUEERS IN MY MEDIA????
dude she's hitting the sprite
AIEEEEE DONT POWERPOINT TRANSITION MEEEE
DEVICE POSTING
without crack it cannot be shot
WHY DOES SHE HAVE A FIGHTING GAME SPECIAL
THIS IS FUCKED UP WHY DID SHE RESPAWN THOSE GUYS TOO
are we just in the Golden Land right now??? just this is straight up canon and real???
THEY GOT BATTLER NOOOO
UHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH this is spooky as shit what the hell
i like this line, "a hundred years of mystery cliches is all you are"
UHHHH DUDE IM SORRY I DIDNT MEAN IT PLEASE DONT TURN TO PASTE
wait wearing off??? just because battler doesn't believe, she's going to/wants to unrevive everyone????
makes sense, they weren't exactly alive last we saw them
JESS GAMING IM SO SORRY
DUDE.
JESS FUCK NO
dude he's crashing out
WHAT THE FUCK MAN WHAT THE HELL ITS OVER????
god i have some thoughts what the hell
OST - Prison strip holy shit this goes insane, this reminds me a lot of Higu Chapter 6's "Night when the Invisible Scares You"
welp. here's our main set of mysteries to solve. I have to find more but i'll see what i think, i need time to sort my thoughts out
huh there's more????? i thought that was gonna be our little avengers postcredit scene and thats it
ABGFUOAEBGIUJHBAEGOUAEGF
OOMFIE WHY ARE YOU HERE
WHY ARE YOU HERE OOMFIE
YOU WERE MEANT TO BE LIKE A CHAPTER 7 THING NOT A CHAPTER 1 THING WHAT
I WAS SURPRISED AT BEATRICE, THIS IS WAY MORE
WELL YEAH THAT WOULD BE HER NAME HUH
3rd witch spotted
is Lambdadelta supposed to be Takano? "Winning an endurance contest" kinda makes me think that, though the rest isn't really there. After all, in Higu, she didn't actually kill everyone in like, 3/5 timeloops. Definitely not "Without fail". But that's the kind of thing a miracle can solve
ENDLESS KILLING HOLY MOLY
also bernkastle's powers are more problematic for Beatrice than her own? wtf
"fragments" yeah dude you think you're so fucking cute don't you. die.
Huh. Some really interesting things to note here. Obviously we have the Higuposting first and foremost, but Beatrice is happy with any roll? Whatever happens, she's fine with it?
I guess that makes sense.
Revive or not, she seems immortal. As long as she is entertained and has fun, it will be a good time for her.
But, nothing inside her? What's her actual goal then? Is it just having fun? Reviving? She doesn't seem too bothered that her magic didn't hold together.
also she is a husk of a person it seems, or at least is completely divorced from ideas such as "endings" if we're going off this "nothing but zero" idea. this idea of "infinite" is also why Bern cannot win i guess. her power is to see and endure new fragments over and over and over. if you can never escape, then yeah, she'd have a shit matchup.
also im wondering if Maria could be Lamdadelta - everyone around her died, she's cruel as fuck and the game described her and Beatrice as "a pair of witches"
something to think about
"dont kill me please :("
WHY DID YOU TURN TO FACE ME
WHY ARENT YOU TALKING IN QUOTATION MARKS ANYMORE
UHHH
interesting. are they saying that Beatrice is a concept then? Like, she is the "desire to be seen by others" or something adequately abstract? hmmmmm
this is very Higu. i got rules to solve.
sounds very similar to Higu. Some rules and actions are constants. Solve them to figure out this world and its tricks
fuck she's back to being a spectator... no...
spooky
cruelest witch in the world???? how are you planning on fighting back against Beatrice? Making her surrender???? scary
WHAT THE FUCK MAN THIS GAME IS FUCKED
oomfie boomfie...
NOOOOOOO IM SORRY I LOVE YOU I SHOULDNT TRY AND EXECUTE YOU
this will be important
welp
dude
WELL THATS CHAPTER 1. TIME TO WRITE UP THE CRAZY AND STUPID QUESTIONS AND THEORIES
okay Maria Theory is the main one i am subscribing to
- Maria possibly met Kinzo at multiple times
- Several times where Maria is left strictly unattended
- During the rain, Kinzo may have met up with her
- During the time when everyone found the first 6 bodies, Maria had like an hour or something where she could run around the house and do whatever she wants to/needs to.
- The crux of Maria theory is that Kinzo + Maria are working together in some capacity, considering the fact that they both have a vested interest in fulfilling the wishes of "Beatrice".
- Maria could have - drawn magic circles, transported bodies, created letters/distributed them at the right places
- She knows her magic nonsense and has a vested interest in making it seem like Beatrice is a real person because she loves witches and wants everyone else to believe in them too
- Could probably use a variety of tricks such as stupid shit to plant letters in advance, or any sorts of stupid tricks. I think if anything like the letter appearing was set up in advance, it was probably Maria
- I also think Kinzo would be alive in this theory (at least for most of the route) - Maria snuck him out in the hour they had, and they had a dead body to pretend to set up in the incinerator
- I am sus of Maria because that one hour is such a gaping hole in the timeline (as well as her waking up before everyone else.
okay then for the rest of questions and stuff--
- Maria's Letter - Stamped by Kinzo/Beato/someone with the ring. Possibly Maria met up with Kinzo and got the letters/ring from him and distributed them around the house when necessary
- How the six were killed - No clue, but strongest guess (weak as fuck) is that one of the adults got in an argument and killed the others in the dining room, and then a servant/Maria finished the job of moving them and drawing the circles. Maria was up before anyone else - possibly messed with the corpses/transported them and drew circle during this time after all are dead
- The shutter - Maria/Kinzo/Servants did it
- The receipt trick on Kinzo's door - I think Eva was lying about the exact height thing. Maria and Kinzo just put it back while meeting up together and Kinzo left his room
- Eva's room locked with the chain - I think Maria tampered with the chain during the period she was alone - she also set up The Device in order to make the red paint appear (hydrophobic paint/something heat reactive for hot shower) and dropped off letter? Receipt trick? Killer came in because sabotaged chain, killed with picks, then left again after setting up letter, and "repairing" the chain again after - doesn't have to be very good, since they had to bolt cutter it after and didnt inspect. Lowkey might be Kinzo after faking disappearance
- Kanon in the boiler room - ONLY kinzo isn't accounted for in this moment. It's either Kinzo (most likely), Kumasawa, Secret 19th Person, Suicide, The Device That Shoots You, or actually Beatrice with magic
- The 3 servants dying at the end - Maria. Nine-year-old Mind Control to say "you guys should give up your lives for disappointing Kinzo and let his wish come true"
- Natsuhi's suicide - She tried to actually shoot Beatrice/19th person but got got (either by them or by a device OR funny ricochet)
- Riddle of the epitaph - EXTREMELY baffling for now. WHY is it that upon resurrection, you get the Gold? The gold is promised in the letter only if you win. So why on earth is it a gift for winning against Beatrice?
- Location of the hidden gold - I dont think i know - probably on the island, since Beatrice said "the single way to kill me is in the palm of your hand." probably very easy to find or something
- Red goop on Natsuhi door - Either blood from Krauss trying to get in and warn her, or Maria going about doing her Maria theory stuff
- Red goop circle on the garden shed door - Maria, Kinzo or probably Genji did it, not necessarily the moving bodies or anything, but just the paint seems possible
- No location that is obviously the crime scene for first 6 - I think it's probably they fought in the main room/there was gas or poison that led to no struggle. Then killed in main room, servants could have been killed anywhere, probably dining room upon being called in. Krauss may have made his way to Natsuhi's door and bled out near it
- Why the heads and faces were smashed in - Probably done by someone alive in order to plant the possibility of Beatrice being someone dead who is still walking around
- The reason why those people were chosen - Random. Done to cast more suspicion on Eva and Kinzo (Natsuhi gains from Eva and Kinzo being suspected) (Kinzo is an alibi for anyone - nobody else knows magic)
- Why the deaths happened at that TIME - Everyone was asleep - night is the least impressive/magical time for a murder to happen. Maria theory explains this quite neatly - it's time for her to skulk or do whatever she wants and she can take all the time she needs to do the rest
- Torii gate missing at the start - ??????
- Why did Rudolf say he thought he was gonna die - He is paranoid and knows tensions are running high because this is the last chance to get the treasure
- EVERYTHING with the witches…….. - I think Beatrice is just a concept who will be defeated as such - everyone will need to refute her or do something like "find love" or something like this in order to win.
- Oh my god i love u bernkastel im so so so so so excited holy shit this game will be awesome